By Jeff Evans

Nose

Pungently oaky – the wholesome smell of a carpenter's shop – with treacley malt behind.

Palate

Decisively woody and tangy, but fairly sweet with a smooth dark malt presence that brings a touch of chocolate. Not a heavy beer.

Finish

Firmly dry, thick and woody, with a little sugary malt lingering on the palate.

Comment

This variation on the Innis & Gunn theme is all about tangy oak, with not too much else in the mix. Pleasant though.

By Glenn Payne

Nose

Distinctively smoked peat that hits immediately.

Palate

Taste is thin with acidic notes hitting but fading quickly.

Finish

Sourness is dominant but is transient.

Comment

Dark brown beer that promises much with aroma but is dominated by sourness.